shweta_narayan (shweta_narayan) wrote,
shweta_narayan
shweta_narayan

I am college-educated; I am not American. Which modifier did I remember to put in That Post?

This post, I mean.

I said, "Able neurotypical not-fat not-poor straight cis white anglophone American Christian men are considered to be prototypical humans."

Someone on boingboing pointed out that college-educated should be in that list. They are absolutely right. I missed it because we are often unaware of the ways in which we match the prototype. The default is unmarked.

Someone on metafilter claimed that I'm falling into my own categorical trap, which I think means projecting my own experience, when I say that Americans are prototypical, since they are a tiny percentage of the global population.  If I interpreted them right then this is wrong, for a few reasons.

1) I'm an Indian national. And, yes I live in the US now, but I didn't when I wrote the post. And I've lived in a lot of countries; US-centrism is a phenomenon I've encountered in all of them. (Consider the impact of white Americans getting killed. The whole world is expected to care. It's just not true for anyone else - unless it plays conveniently into existing bigotries/narratives of course.)

2) Percentage is irrelevant. Americans' position (in the absence of other context) as global prototype human has to do with their global power and prestige, and their extremely effective imperialism.

3) Going back to college-educated - if I were American, I probably wouldn't have thought to put that modifier on the list. Like I didn't think to put college-educated on the list. The default is unmarked - and the way I fall into my own categorical trap is in the things I don't notice.

----

Having said all that - prototypes absolutely do vary between people & communities, based on experience; and relevant categories and thus prototypes do absolutely shift with context. Take all generalizations as exactly that.
Tags: categorization, nitpicks, or further thoughts, something like that
Subscribe

  • *floppy wave* hi have pome

    My poem Tatakai, and interview about poem and such, are up on Strange Horizons! (And psst SH still has a fund drive going!) *floppy wave yes* I…

  • Goblin Fruit!

    It's fabulous and I'm proud to be in it :) That's all from me for now. Tooo tired to go into every awesome poem (cause they ALL are), sorry.…

  • all the things, plus a mippo

    Hi! I am still (again) sick. Big surprise. But still not dead, lj evidence to the contrary. 1) Am in California, catching all the fun California…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 16 comments

  • *floppy wave* hi have pome

    My poem Tatakai, and interview about poem and such, are up on Strange Horizons! (And psst SH still has a fund drive going!) *floppy wave yes* I…

  • Goblin Fruit!

    It's fabulous and I'm proud to be in it :) That's all from me for now. Tooo tired to go into every awesome poem (cause they ALL are), sorry.…

  • all the things, plus a mippo

    Hi! I am still (again) sick. Big surprise. But still not dead, lj evidence to the contrary. 1) Am in California, catching all the fun California…